Hello everyone.
We are moving on through Luke 20. Today, we will examine verses 27-40, where Jesus' detractors have run out of ways to trap and in their final last gasp start reaching for the absurd. He is my translation:
27 Some of those who were Sadducees came to him. (They claim that there is no resurrection.) They asked him, 28 “Teacher, Moses wrote for us, ‘If a married man dies, without children, then the man’s brother is to take the wife and raise up offspring for him.’ 29 So, there were seven brothers. The first one took a wife, but then died without children. 30 The thing happened with the second brother, 31 and then the third brother took her as his wife. Eventually, all seven brothers married her, but died without leaving any offspring. 32 Then finally, the wife died. 33 When the resurrection comes, whose wife will she be, since all seven brothers were married to her?
34 Jesus responded to them, “The children of this age marry and are given in marriage, 35 but those who are considered worthy to take part in that age and be raised from the dead, will neither marry nor be given in marriage. 36 Those who experience that age will no longer die, but will be like the angels. They are children of God, since they are children of the resurrection. 37 The dead rise. Moses illustrates this, when the bush declares that the Lord is ‘the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob.’ 38 He is not the God of the dead, but of the living, because to Him, all are alive.”
39 Some among the experts of the law responded, “Well said, Teacher!” 40 After that, no one dared to ask him any more questions.
The Sadducees are next attempt to entrap Jesus. They lay out a “what if” trap that is, in reality, just silly. Jesus’ response to their question is awesome.
Their question involved the levirate marriage talked about in the Old Testament, where if a man dies without offspring, his brother will take his wife and produce offspring for the brother. (Deut. 25:5-10) In the Sadducees ‘what if’ story, the widow has been married to seven brothers, and they question Jesus as to which of these brothers she would be married to in the afterlife.
Now, since the Sadducees do not believe in an afterlife, they really thought that they had stumped Jesus. They had asked him a question for which there is no good answer. However, their question carries an absurdity to it that really makes it pointless, like the question, “If God is all-powerful, can He make a rock so heavy that even He can’t lift it?” It's stupid and irrational.
According to Mark’s account. Jesus responds to their question by saying that they are in error for two reasons: 1) they do not understand the scriptures, and 2) they do not understand the power of God. They came trying to discredit Jesus, but he discredits them.
Richard Foster describes these men in his book Life With God. He says, "The religious professionals of Jesus' day were blind to their true place...they devoted themselves to performance...It was a dry, lifeless process, not a journey of understanding, because it devoid of the living Author." (Foster, 79.) Foster is correct in his assessment, Jesus is dealing with really religious people, who don't really understand the Scriptures, or know God, and Jesus is not afraid to tell them that.
As for the Sadducees, they valued the Torah and rejected everything else. So, Jesus goes into their home territory to dispute their silly argument.
Luke omits part of Jesus' response, but then says that in the afterlife people will not be married or given in marriage, but instead, will be like the angels. Jesus says “those who experience that age,” implying that some will not experience that age. He also states that this new age will not be like this age. I’m not sure what it will be like, but it will be different then what we understand from this life. We won’t be married and we will be like the angels. (He doesn’t say that we will be angels, but he does say that we will like them.)
The Sadducees are trying to show the absurdity of the Resurrection, but Jesus shows the absurdity of their question with his response. He shows that their understanding of the Resurrection is too grounded in this life. The life in the Resurrection will be much grander than anything we experience in this life.
Then Jesus turns to Moses and the burning bush. God speaks from the bush, declaring that He is the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. “Is,” not ‘was.’ The implication here is that even though they died on this Earth, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob live with God, and are not dead. God is the God of the living, and not the God of the dead. The Sadducees tried to bring Moses in to invalidate Jesus, but Jesus used Moses on them, to show them how incorrect they were.
In verse 40, Luke concludes that after this, no one dared to ask any more questions, Jesus has entered this house, the temple and bound up the strong men, the Pharisees, Sadducees and Herodians. Every attempt to discredit Jesus had failed.